Hester Prynne (Lillian Gish) is punished for playing on the Sabbath Day, but reverend Arthur Dimmesdale (Lars Hanson) takes pity on her. They begin to spend time together by taking walks in the woods, and gradually fall in love. A wedding between the two, however, is impossible, because Hester is already married to Roger Prynne (Henry B. Walthall), a physician who has been away for seven years [and may or may not be dead].
When Hester gives birth to a child, she is forced to wear the letter "A" for adultery. Instead of naming Dimmesdale as Pearl's father, Hester chooses to protect him and publicly bear the shame alone.
Dimmesdale, who
baptizes Pearl, struggles with his own grief and shame, eventually etching an "A" into his own flesh, as penance for his tortured heart.
And what happens next when Hester's husband returns, discovering her and Dimmesdale's secret?
Interesting Notes:
- This film was based on the novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne.
- Because this story was on the censored list, Lillian Gish had to spend much time campaigning for permission to make the film. She was successful and secured Swedes Lars Hanson and Victor Sjöström for her co-star and director, respectively.
- Lillian Gish performed her scenes in English, while Lars Hanson did his in Swedish.
Thoughts:
The Scarlet Letter is one of my favorite books, and I truly love this film adaptation. It's not exactly like the novel, but in some ways, it's even a bit better. I especially like how time is spent on the development of Hester's and Dimmesdale's relationship.
The acting is absolutely perfect. Lillian Gish and Lars Hanson were both such excellent silent actors, and the characters' emotions, particularly those of love and anguish, play out amazingly well. The part when Hester walks up to the scaffold, and reveals her love for her unnamed partner in sin as well as her 'brand of shame,' while Dimmesdale looks on despairingly, is one of the most gorgeous bits I've ever seen. Eyes and expressions say so much more than words ever could. I also love the scene in the woods, when Hester removes both her scarlet letter and bonnet, and Dimmesdale gently caresses her long, loose hair. And that powerful, poignant ending is just gloriously done.
Unfortunately, this film is rather hard to find. I was luckily able to enjoy
The Scarlet Letter in its entirety online over a year ago, but the movie has since been removed, and I have been unable to locate it anywhere else thus far. I would love to see this again; it certainly is a gorgeous movie and deserves more attention!
EDIT (MARCH 2011): The entire lovely film is currently available online
here! I was so excited to finally see it again, and it's even better than I remembered. ♥
TCM will also be airing this movie on
June 26, 2011 at 12:00 AM. I'll definitely be recording it so I can have my own hard copy of it at last.
EDIT (MAY 2012): Lillian will be one of the actresses featured on TCM's 2012
Summer Under The Stars! A whole day of her films will be broadcast on
Wednesday, August 15th, 2012 and one of the titles featured will be
The Scarlet Letter at 12:15 PM!
Rating:
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
One of my all-time favorites.